apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Good Question: Suggestions for Cooking Without Onions?

2008_10_21-NoOnions.jpgHelp! We all know the best way to a man's (and woman's) heart is through the stomach. I started dating someone who's system doesn't tolerate onions, garlic, shallots, cilantro, etc. very well.

Over 90% of my cooking repertoire contains at least one of those key ingredients! What can I cook for him?

Pasta is on this week's menu, but I'm already having to alter my sauce recipe fairly significantly so that he can eat it.

Thanks!
Ginger

Good - and tough - question, Ginger! We can't imagine a life without alliums, and we're sympathetic to anyone who has to. Still, this might be a great opportunity for some culinary creativity! Here are some of our thoughts:

 
 

If your date is merely sensitive and not actually allergic to onions and their ilk, we wonder if a different cooking method might do the trick. Techniques like caramelizing onions and slow-roasting the garlic neutralize the harsh compounds in alliums, most often rendering them sweet and succulent. He might also be able to handle milder alliums like leeks.

If using onions, garlic, etc. is completely out, turn your attention to other ingredients. Celery and carrots are the other two ingredients in a chef's mirepoix flavor base, and these vegetables can build a lot of flavor in your dish even without onions. Cooking with broth, wine, and other liquids instead of water will also give your dish added body and flavor. Play around with the spices and aromatics in your favorite recipes to see what other flavors you can bring out.

Since onions are key for layered dishes like braises and sauces, you might also think about simpler preparations with fewer ingredients and meals with multiple side dishes, like stuffed chicken breast with mashed potatoes and a salad.

Hopefully this at least gives you somewhere to start! Anyone else have suggestions for Ginger?

(Image: Onion Set by Chris Burrows, available for $39.99 from AllPosters.com)

Tags

Good Questions, Tips & Techniques, Ingredients - Vegetables, onions, alliums

Related Links

Share

Comments (14)

I've made spaghetti sauce from scratch without onions before (I had run out and didn't know it!). Instead, I substituted finely diced carrots and celery. It turned out really well. It was sweeter than usual, but I tweaked it with some good Balsamic vinegar and it had that twang.

Another idea for pasta is to use spicy peppers in the sauce. Try cubanells (sp?). they might add a nice spicy flavour that wouldn't make you think "Hmmm..where's the onion?"

Also, can your date have garlic powder? I always find myself adding it even when I have fresh garlic in a recipe.

posted by revolution9 on October 21st 2008 at 11:14am
view revolution9's profile

Try researching traditional Buddhist recipes - traditional Buddhists avoid garlic, onions, etc. My parents love Asian restaurants because the Buddhist-run ones will leave out garlic and onions (which they strongly dislike) on request.

posted by Stiletto on October 21st 2008 at 11:50am
view Stiletto's profile

I just made a sweet potato gnocchi with brown butter and sage (no onions or garlic)! Taaaaasty.

posted by aliciak on October 21st 2008 at 12:05pm
view aliciak's profile

Whoops, forgot the link: http://www.aliciakachmar.com/blog/food/sweet-potato-gnocchi-with-brown-butter-and-sage/

posted by aliciak on October 21st 2008 at 12:05pm
view aliciak's profile

how abt pesto(basil, olive oil, pinenuts, lime/lemon juice) with pasta, and chicken stuffed with goat cheese,coated in almonds?

posted by daiz on October 21st 2008 at 1:40pm
view daiz's profile

I do not like onions in any form-green, red, white, chives, shallots, leeks, anything!
I merely omit them from recipes. Can't say I've had any complaints by doing this (though I do use garlic so maybe thats why).
Pastas, soups, stews, meat & potato dinners, mexican food, indian food...I make it all without onions.

posted by truenic on October 21st 2008 at 1:44pm
view truenic's profile

leeks might be a good substitue for onions.
nothing can replace garlic...but for a date...maybe thats a good thing. :)
I Love Basil...have your sauce...which I'm guessing is red...be robust with basil and maybe different bell peppers.

You could go another route, try a vodka sauce (lots of flavor) the onions and garlic won't be missed.

If all else fails, you could stop dating him. LOL ok mean joke...sorry

posted by nickel525 on October 21st 2008 at 1:53pm
view nickel525's profile

If you (and he) have adventurous palates otherwise, try recipes from Yamuna Devi's Lord Krishna's Cuisine: The Art of Indian Vegetarian Cooking. It has thousands of Indian recipes without a single allium! Her other cookbook, Yamuna's Table, was also low on onions and garlic, if memory serves (I used to cook from both of them frequently, before children!).

posted by kyoko71 on October 21st 2008 at 2:04pm
view kyoko71's profile

there's a hindu sect that does not eat garlic or any variety of onion,they substitute an herb called acefadieta sometimes called hing.

posted by ancientsm on October 21st 2008 at 3:54pm
view ancientsm's profile

my mom has an allium sensitivity as well--with things like spaghetti sauce, chilis, soups, and stews, she'll put a quartered onion in cheesecloth and just soak it in the food while it cooks to infuse the flavor. then she takes it out.

i'm sure this is not foolproof, but it might be something worth trying once you get to know each other better.

in the meantime, although i love onions, i find that you can do without pretty easily--fajitas with just peppers, for example, or replacing them with celery and carrots.

also, the above advice to use sweet vinegars in place of onion is good. my mom does that. she keeps balsamic and sherry around. cooking with wine helps, too.

posted by thinkingwoman on October 21st 2008 at 5:17pm
view thinkingwoman's profile

That's my husband! I have to really cook all of those things before he'll eat it. For flavor we add things he does like... black pepper, mustard, and hot spices like cayenne pepper, chili powder, and hot pepper flakes. And tons of cheese on top.

posted by Knerq on October 22nd 2008 at 4:11am
view Knerq's profile

I often cook for a friend who's stomach is sensitive to biggish chunks of allium, but she said it's fine if the chunks are so big that she can remove them or so small (finely minced) that she can't see them. Using things like Penzy's dried onion or even onion powder has worked okay, and most of the time, just omitting the allium from standard recipes has worked out fine, too--just taste as you cook and adjust the other seasonings as necessary. Staples like worcestershire sauce and other fermented condiments might add a nice depth of flavor (something like umami) when you have to omit your onions.

posted by OneWallKitchen on October 22nd 2008 at 6:16am
view OneWallKitchen's profile

My hubby's the same way. You need to really consider whether this person is worth dating before preceding. If you both are looking for a long term relationship you may find yourself unable to cook or even EAT onions and garlic for the rest of your life.

My husband has slowly increased his tolerance. He can now tolerate very, very finely chopped garlic and onions in small amounts, or very large chopped onions that he can pick out. He even lets me eat onions and small amounts of garlic if I brush, floss, brush and use Listerine. This was not the case when we first dated, so ask first! He hates caramelized onions and leeks and whatever other milder onion type thing, so ask before substituting those. Basically I cook all my normal recipes, but just skip the garlic and onions. Before our relationship I used to start every savory recipe with sauteing garlic and onions first. If that's how he's used to eating he won't notice the difference and eventually neither will you. I've lost my taste for garlic bread! We've been together 6 years now, so run away if this isn't the fate you want ;-)

I have noticed the amount of colds I've had going way up too. I think the massive amounts of garlic and onions were protecting me. Luckily I love him and I'm willing to tolerate some colds for him :-)

posted by Ariel on October 22nd 2008 at 7:07am
view Ariel's profile

thanks for all the suggestions everyone! unfortunately, the relationship didn't last and the issue isn't one anymore. hopefully the suggestions here can help others with sensitive palates.

for a little more background, his body couldn't process alliums in any state-- caramelized, cooked, raw, powdered. he was also lactose intolerant. we ended up eating a lot of asian and sauceless foods (anything he saw, he would pick out but there were some he missed as we would find out later in the evening).

this relationship truly tested my culinary expertise. my condolences to those with celiac disease and any other food allergies!
-ginger

posted by Amandica on October 22nd 2008 at 12:26pm
view Amandica's profile